The Ultimate Guide to Accommodation Options in Exuma Bahamas for Every Budget
- Cari
- 4 days ago
- 6 min read
Best Hotels and Vacation Rentals from Budget to Luxury
If you are planning a trip to Exuma, one of the first things you will realize is that where you stay matters. The islands are spread out, the beaches vary depending on location, and the overall vibe can range from quiet local charm to full luxury resort living.
The good news is there is something here for every type of traveler. You do not need a luxury budget to enjoy Exuma, but if you want a private villa with an infinity pool overlooking turquoise water, that option exists too.
Below is our curated list of the best places to stay in Exuma based on location, value, and traveler experience. We have organized them by budget, mid-range, and luxury to help you find the right fit for your trip. We also recommend a rental car no matter where you stay in Exuma.
Budget Friendly Places to Stay in Exuma
Exuma is not known as a “cheap” Caribbean destination, but there are several great options that offer beachfront access and island charm without the luxury price tag.
Best for couples, relaxed travelers, and quiet beach lovers.
Paradise Bay is one of the best value stays in Exuma if you want the classic laid back island experience. The colorful cottages sit directly on a quiet stretch of beach on the north side of Great Exuma. This property feels like old school Bahamas. No large resort crowds, just hammocks, kayaks, and turquoise water.
Why we like it• Private beach with incredible sunsets• Complimentary kayaks and paddleboards• Affordable cottages with ocean views• Quiet location away from crowds
Best for families and longer stays.
Hideaways is one of the most popular budget friendly resorts in Exuma because the accommodations are actually condo style villas. Many units include kitchens, multiple bedrooms, and plenty of space. The location near George Town also makes it convenient to reach restaurants, grocery stores, and tour operators.
Why we like it • Great value for families • Beachfront location • Pool and restaurant on site • Spacious villa style units
Peace & Play Villa is a place we have personally stayed, and it ended up being one of those properties that just feels easy to settle into. The location is fantastic and the surrounding villas create a small neighborhood feel that makes the stay feel comfortable and relaxed. The villa itself is bright, spacious, and very clean with open living areas, high ceilings, and a wraparound porch that’s perfect for morning coffee or evening sunsets. While the interior is not the most modern compared to some newer builds in Exuma, it is extremely well kept and offers incredible value for the price. We especially loved the beachfront setting and the saltwater pool just steps from the house. Guests can swim in the ocean, kayak out toward the mangroves, or relax under the palms before grabbing a drink from the honor bar near the beach. With three comfortable bedrooms, a full kitchen with stainless steel appliances, and plenty of space to spread out, Peace & Play is a great option for families or small groups looking for a laid-back beachfront villa in Exuma.
Mid Range Hotels and Villas in Exuma
These properties offer the best balance between comfort, location, and price. For many travelers, this is the sweet spot.
Best for couples, boaters, and social travelers.
Peace and Plenty sits in the heart of George Town overlooking the harbor. It is one of the most historic hotels in Exuma and a favorite gathering spot for travelers and boaters.
One of the biggest perks is their private beach club on Stocking Island, which guests can access by boat from the marina.
Why we like it • Walkable to restaurants and shops • Fun social atmosphere • Access to Stocking Island beach club • Beautiful marina views
Best for couples and small groups.
Ocean Mist is the type of villa travelers picture when they think of an Exuma vacation. It features incredible ocean views, modern design, and direct access to the water.
It is ideal for travelers who want privacy while still being close to George Town and excursions.
Why we like it • Beautiful oceanfront location • Modern interiors and open spaces • Perfect for couples' trips or friends traveling together
Best for couples or small groups. One of our favorite places to stay. Sea Star Villa offers a great balance of privacy and beach access. Staying in a villa like this is one of the best ways to experience Exuma because it gives you space to relax, cook meals, and enjoy the island at your own pace.
Why we like it • Spacious private rental • Ocean views and beach access • Fantastic outside area
Luxury Stays in Exuma
If your dream vacation includes private beaches, infinity pools, and world class ocean views, Exuma has several spectacular options.
Best for luxury travelers, families, and golf lovers.
Grand Isle sits on Emerald Bay, one of the most beautiful beaches in the Bahamas. The accommodations are large luxury villas that feel more like private homes than hotel rooms.
The resort is also next to the Sandals Emerald Bay golf course, one of the most scenic oceanfront golf courses in the Caribbean.
Why we like it • One of the most beautiful beaches in Exuma • Large luxury villas perfect for families • Stunning infinity pool • Close to golf and marina
Best for honeymoons and bucket list trips.
Most people think you have to travel to Bora Bora or the Maldives to experience an overwater bungalow. Surprisingly, Exuma offers one of these rare accommodations in the Bahamas.
The Overwater Bungalow near Georgetown provides a unique stay where you can wake up directly above the water with incredible turquoise views in every direction.
Why we like it • Unique overwater villa experience • Incredible views and privacy • Perfect for special occasions or honeymoons
Best for luxury groups and family gatherings.
We will be staying here when this villa in finished in a few months, and we so excited for this property! Villa Blue is one of the newest luxury villas being built in Exuma and is expected to become one of the most sought-after properties on the island. This high-end villa features modern architecture, incredible water views, and the privacy that comes with staying in your own luxury home. We love the south side location away from the crowds and has its own private cove.
Why we like it • Brand new luxury property, sleeps 12 • Stunning ocean views • Perfect for group trips or extended family travel.
Seaclusion is one of those rare beachfront homes that feels like your own private slice of Exuma. Located on stunning Tar Bay, this five-bedroom villa sits just steps from the sand, about 13 meters from the water. The beach here is calm, secluded, and exactly what travelers picture when they dream about the Bahamas. Guests can relax on beach loungers, take out the kayaks, or simply spend the day enjoying the crystal-clear turquoise water right outside the door. Tar Bay is known for its soft sand and excellent snorkeling conditions, making it perfect for swimming, paddleboarding, or quiet sunset walks along the shore. With spacious accommodations and an unbeatable beachfront location, Seaclusion is an incredible option for families or groups looking for a private luxury stay in Exuma.
Tips for Booking Your Stay in Exuma
Rent a car. Exuma is a spread-out island, and taxis can become expensive quickly. Renting a car makes exploring much easier. We recommend Thompson's Car Rentals, Berlie's Car Rental, or Zoom Car Rental.
Book early. Exuma has fewer hotels than many Caribbean destinations, so the best places often sell out months in advance.
Final Thoughts
Exuma is one of the most beautiful island destinations in the Caribbean. The water is unbelievably blue, the beaches are uncrowded, and the pace of life is refreshingly slow.
Whether you are looking for a laid-back beachfront cottage, a comfortable villa, or a luxury resort experience, there is a place to stay here for every type of traveler.
Choosing the right location can shape your entire experience on the island, so it is worth taking the time to find the property that best matches your travel style.
Affiliate Disclosure
Some of the links in this article may be affiliate links. If you book through them, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. We only recommend hotels and vacation rentals we truly believe provide a great experience for travelers visiting Exuma.
Your support helps us continue creating free travel guides, island itineraries, and helpful resources for our travel community.